Bug Report Fix First Tile Green Triggers Submit New Row Gate Confirm And Add Tooltips

Hey guys! We've got a bit of a bug report here that we need to dive into. It's all about how our app reacts when the first tile turns green, plus some ideas on how to make things even smoother with the Confirm button and helpful tooltips. Let's break it down!

Summary

Okay, so here's the gist of it. When you flip that first tile to green, the app goes a little trigger-happy. It's like it thinks you're done and immediately tries to submit or recompute, and sometimes even adds a fresh new row. Now, changing a tile's color should be chill, right? It shouldn't be rushing to submit anything or start a new row on its own. We also need to talk about the Confirm button, it should be a bit more selective about when it's ready to roll. And those buttons without tooltips? Let's get them some helpful labels so everyone knows what they do.

Steps to Reproduce

Alright, wanna see this in action? Here's how you can make it happen:

1. Fire up the app.
2. Type in a word – any word will do!
3. Now, toggle that first tile to the glorious green.
4. Watch closely! You'll probably see the recommendations running and maybe even a new row popping up if your current row is complete. Spooky, right?

Expected Behavior

So, what should happen? Glad you asked! Here's the dream scenario:

• Toggling any tile's color, even that first one turning green, should only change the color. No hidden agendas, just pure color vibes.
• No sneaky automatic submits or new row creations just because a color changed. We're in control here!
• That Confirm button? It should be a bit of a VIP. Disabled until the current row is a complete word. No half-finished business allowed!
• And for the love of clarity, let's get some helpful tooltips on all those buttons. Knowledge is power, people!

Root Cause Analysis

Time to put on our detective hats and figure out why this is happening. Turns out, there's a little mischief-maker in the code. The controller is triggering a recompute when that first tile turns green. Here's where the action is:

• lib/state/solver_state.dart
  • setTileFeedback(...) calls requestRecommendations() when colIndex == 0 && nextColor == TileFeedback.green. Sneaky!
  • setFeedbackAtSelection(...) also calls requestRecommendations() when idx == 0 && nextColor == TileFeedback.green. Double trouble!

This little maneuver can gobble up the current row and slap a new one on the screen if the row is complete. Not cool!

Proposed Fix

Okay, we've found the culprit, now let's fix it! Here's the plan:

• Remove the implicit recompute in both of those methods. Color changes are just color changes, no submitting allowed.
• Gate that Confirm button! It should be disabled until the current row is a complete word (you know, with actual letters in it). We'll keep the existing validation on press, just to be sure.
• Tooltips for everyone! Let's add those helpful little labels to all the buttons that are missing them. We're talking Confirm, New, Submit, those Green/Yellow color pickers, and even the Clear Prefix button. No button left behind!

Diving Deeper into the Fix: A Comprehensive Approach to Enhancing User Experience

In order to truly tackle the issues at hand, we need a multi-faceted approach that addresses the root causes and ensures a smoother, more intuitive user experience. Let's delve deeper into each aspect of the proposed fix:

First and foremost, the premature triggering of recompute when the first tile turns green needs immediate attention. This behavior not only disrupts the user's flow but also introduces unnecessary computational overhead. By removing the implicit recompute in the setTileFeedback(...) and setFeedbackAtSelection(...) methods, we ensure that color changes remain purely visual, allowing users to experiment with different combinations without the app prematurely jumping to conclusions. This single adjustment drastically improves the responsiveness of the application and provides a more controlled environment for the user.

Next, the gating of the Confirm button is a crucial step in preventing accidental submissions and ensuring that users are fully committed to their chosen word before proceeding. By disabling the button until a complete word is entered, we enforce a deliberate action, reducing the likelihood of errors and enhancing the user's sense of control. This simple yet effective mechanism aligns the app's behavior with the user's intent, leading to a more satisfying and error-free experience.

Finally, the addition of tooltips to all relevant buttons is a cornerstone of user-centered design. Tooltips serve as gentle nudges, providing context and guidance to users without cluttering the interface. For buttons like Confirm, New, Submit, color pickers, and Clear Prefix, tooltips can make a significant difference in discoverability and ease of use. By offering concise explanations of each button's function, we empower users to explore the app's features with confidence and reduce the learning curve. This commitment to clarity not only improves the user experience for newcomers but also enhances the efficiency of seasoned users.

In conclusion, the proposed fix is not merely a band-aid solution but a holistic approach to refining the app's functionality and user interface. By addressing the root causes of the reported bug and incorporating thoughtful design enhancements, we can create a more robust, intuitive, and enjoyable application for all users.

Acceptance Criteria

Let's make sure we nail this thing! Here's what we need to see to call it a win:

• Changing that first tile to green should never trigger a submit or create a new row. We want zero tolerance for sneaky submissions.
• The Confirm button should be a wallflower until the row is complete. Disabled until further notice!
• Tooltips should be partying on all the relevant buttons. We're talking Confirm/New/Submit/color pickers/Clear Prefix. Everyone gets a tooltip!
• The existing manual Submit flow should be as smooth as ever. No changes there, just good old-fashioned submitting.

Notes

Just a heads-up, prefix deduction should still do its thing when you hit that explicit Submit button. No need to mess with that. We're just focusing on those rogue recomputes and making sure our buttons are behaving.

Expanding on the Notes: Ensuring a Seamless Transition and Maintaining Core Functionality

When implementing fixes and enhancements, it's crucial to consider the broader implications and ensure that core functionalities remain intact. In this case, we need to pay close attention to how the proposed changes affect the prefix deduction mechanism, which plays a vital role in the app's overall performance and user experience.

The note regarding prefix deduction highlights the importance of preserving the existing submit behavior. While we're addressing the issue of implicit recomputes triggered by color changes, we don't want to inadvertently disrupt the app's ability to intelligently deduce and suggest words based on the entered prefixes. This functionality is a key component of the app's efficiency and contributes significantly to the user's ability to solve puzzles quickly and effectively.

Therefore, it's imperative that the modifications made to address the bug are carefully scoped and thoroughly tested to ensure that the prefix deduction mechanism continues to operate as intended. This may involve conducting regression tests to verify that the submit behavior remains unchanged and that the app's word suggestion capabilities are not negatively impacted.

Furthermore, it's worth considering whether there are any opportunities to further optimize the prefix deduction mechanism as part of this broader effort. While the primary focus is on fixing the bug and enhancing user interface elements, a holistic approach to software development often involves identifying areas where improvements can be made in tandem with bug fixes. By exploring potential optimizations, we can ensure that the app not only functions correctly but also delivers the best possible performance and user experience.

In summary, the note about prefix deduction underscores the importance of a balanced approach to software maintenance. While addressing bugs is essential, it's equally crucial to preserve core functionalities and explore opportunities for optimization. By adhering to this principle, we can ensure that the app remains robust, efficient, and user-friendly in the long run.

Alright, that's the plan! Let's get those colors behaving, buttons gated, and tooltips popping. This will make the app so much smoother for everyone!